Loved everything about this place, from the beers to the food to the ambiance tothe service. Too many sours for my taste among the homebrewed offerings bit great for those who prefer them. The two red ales I consumed were delicious and went well with a burger and fries. Our bartender, Laura, was fantastic, making recommendations and putting up with our sophomoric attempts at humor. If she is working when you are there, ask her to play music roulette. You don't be sorry!! Definitely will be back to try other beers and food items!!
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Burger
This is the first time I left a restaurant without eating and asked for a refund. The 6 of us arrived sometime after 6, I believe we ordered around 630. We didn’t get our food until after 8. About 40-45 minutes after we ordered, I was told there was no salmon left for the BLT so I ordered a different meal.
It’s so weird, the food seemed at once rushed and yet completely forgotten? It had been sitting out for an unknown period of time: hamburgers were way over cooked (well done instead of medium rare), the cheese on the Mac and cheese had begun to cool and coagulate, chicken was dry, charred and tasteless, they didn’t give me my side of fries, my salad had little to no dressing and my fiancé’s fries were soggy and limp and everything was lukewarm. All the food was wonderfully described on the menu, but seeing (and tasting) them left a lot to be desired. The waitress was apologetic and offered a free round of beers.
Sometime after that, she said she could see our food in the serving window, however we didn’t receive it until almost a half hour later. One of my friends pointed out that she saw someone in the kitchen taking a big swig of beer and judging by the state of the food… yikes.
After we asked for a refund, the waitress added that she refunded more than the free round of beer, but upon inspection of the receipts, that’s not the case. One positive note: the beer IS good …so maybe they should stick with brewing.
Go to Troeg’s instead.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
I had the privilege to dine here last night. I say “privilege” because the experience was incredible. Their Valentine’s specials were so tasty (I had crab cakes. 10/10). Their menu was full of options including gluten free selections and seasonal fare. Their cocktail and bar selection is great as well. They had a curated bourbon/whiskey selection with a Four Roses promotion event along with live music. Ang was an incredible bartender and she set the overall vibe of the bar. It was fun, but relaxed and it was so comforting to be around. I will definitely be returning here. If you’re in the Hershey area, be sure to stop by!
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
I have mixed feelings about this place. The food is fantastic. We had the brisket burnt ends and the deviled eggs. What really makes me think twice about returning is the service. The waitress didn't put any effort into giving us options or helping us with the menu. She didn't try to even pretent to be accomodating when I asked some questions. There were some beers I really wanted to try. I asked if I could buy one can instead of a four pack. The waitress was very condescending, telling me to look on the other side of the menu for the draft list. She gave me no options at all, which is a shame because I love beer and probably would have bought a 4-pack to share with our group but she basically shot down that idea. I understand that we were a "big" group (we were seven) but the place wasn't busy and a little bit of courtesy goes a long way. She didn't even asked if we wanted to buy anything to-go. She just brought the check and we had to ask. I also find it curious that there's no way to buy a beer to-go from the ones on draft. Can't we get a crowler? If the option exists, it wasn't given to us. The sad thing is, I know Rotunda has some great beers because I've have some in the past. But I would be hesitant to recommend this place to others. I know local breweries where the beer is great and the service is top notch.
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 4
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
Recommended dishes
Deviled Eggs with Oysters
10/10!
Super friendly staff, the atmosphere is very inviting. The food! OMG! Cajun Alfredo Chicken Tortellini was phenomenal!
We are definitely coming back!
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Deviled Eggs with Oysters
Tough decision on whether to give a one- or two- star rating here, but I'll go with two because the atmosphere is pretty cool, my old fashioned was average, and the service wasn't terrible. The food, on the other hand, was well before average. This, plus above average prices, equals low rating. On top of this, they have a credit card surcharge, which to me is a slap in the face of the customers. My new year's resolution is to avoid going to places with a credit card surcharge, which actually seems pretty easy to achieve. Most places aren't so disrespectful of their customers.
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 1
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 4
Very disappointed. Vegetarian mushroom cheese steak barely had any mushrooms. Southwest Salad was bland. Extremely pricey. And a credit card surcharge on top of it all.
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 1
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 3
The food and service is excellent!! The bar selection is amazing!! Definitely worth a visit!
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheeseburger
