Best pie i have ever had in my life. I’ve tried apple, apple cinnamon roll, key lime, coconut cream, berry, pumpkin and lemon and they are all 🔥 🔥 🔥. Keep trying to order more but she’s always sold old because these pies are amazing!! 🤤
Service
Take out
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Apple Pie
If you’re looking for pie look no further!! Shannon is absolutely phenomenal from start to finish - the ordering process is so incredibly easy and very detailed so you know exactly what you’re ordering and when you’re getting it. If you ever have questions or requests, Shannon is extremely responsive and ensures that you will be receiving exactly what you’re wanting. Her memory and/or organizational skills are impeccable - I can’t tell you how many times she’s remembered every detail, even if it’s weeks later.
When your pie is ready - pickup is so easy. She has the cutest pie setup in her pie kitchen that makes things very smooth, even if you’re picking up for a major holiday.
Now the pie - this pie is INCREDIBLE! I’ve had the apple, apple berry, Marion berry, peach, pumpkin, pecan, key lime, lemon raspberry cream, and the chocolate chess pie — they are all perfect! I can’t tell you how many multiples I’ve gotten of the key lime pie. Most recently I had the apple with 1/3 sugar and peach, and they were both absolutely made to perfection. Now I want to order more pie 😂
I almost don’t want to share this because they go so fast and I want to be able to get one - but make sure and follow her social pages - she will post flash pies that she’s made extra of so even if you don’t want to plan in advance, these last minute pies are always a winner.
Bottom line, if you want a pie lady, you’ve got one 🥧
5 stars hardly is enough for these pies! Rumble in my Tumbly pies are heavenly! You can taste all the love and care she puts into making each and every one. I truly have not had a bad one ever. The flavors are spectacular and the crust is perfection. If you love pie you simply must try hers! She is a specialty baker and a small (tiny) business so please be patient she is not a machine and can only make a limited number of pies so order In advance for special occasions and holidays and be flexible! You will not regret it because these pies are that good!
These are the best looking and tastiest pies I have enjoyed in a long long time... the presentation packaging is lovely, the look of each pie has so much time and care put into it... and the taste... wow... the classic Apple Pie is heavy (weight), filled with apple and cinnamon and so so tasty!! Its hard enought to find a banana cream pie... and when I do I'm usually disappointed... but this one was layered with bananas, custard and cream that was delectable...
I cant wait to try the berry pies and others...
Place an order... give them a try... you will be pleasantly surprised and will have a huge smile on your face during that first bite!!
Awesome pies, friendly, easy pick up. Have ordered twice -peach pie for my mom's birthday (they even added her age in pie crust) and pecan for the holidays. Definitely recommend.
Do yourself a favor and try one of these pies. There's a reason you have to book far in advance to get your hands on one of them. The Death by Chocolate pie almost gave me diabetes in the best way possible because I could not stop eating it. I had to pace myself by only allowing myself to eat a small bite every day and even that didn't last long. Between two people, we ate the entire pie in less than a week and that's coming from someone who is conscious about eating too much sugar.
I wish my photos did the designs more justice but I was too eager to eat my way through these things to stop and take good photos. Try this pie before you die.
We ordered a key lime pie and it was incredible! A perfect amount of limey tartness and amazing whipped cream on top to balance the flavors out wonderfully. We can’t wait to try all of the other beautiful and delicious sounding pie flavors. 😊 I’m thankful to have stumbled upon Rumbly In My Tumbly Pies on Facebook!
Shannon's pies are showstoppers. Never have I ever had to ask her "what's in it?" Flavors, textures, and aroma are always thoughtfully put together. Rumbly in My Tumbly is who I order from when I want to treat myself or celebrate with ease. There isn't another chain bakery, restaurant, or other pie shop in this region that I entrust with my pie cravings. Order 2, order early, and try EVERYTHING.
Shannon was INCREDIBLE! Amazing communication during the whole process. We pre-ordered some pies for a birthday party and she EXCEEDED our expectations. Not only were the pies beautiful, but they were probably some of the best tasting pies we’ve ever had. Everyone in the party agreed! We could not stop raving about them. Her pies are show stopping pieces to any party. She is now our go to pie gal!
Discovered Rumbly in my Tumbly Pie Co recently and have already purchased three pies! These are easily the best pies I’ve ever tried. One was a gift for a friend after surgery, one I brought to an event, and one was just for me and my husband. Everyone who has tried these pies gives rave reviews. Pick up is super easy, you pull up to the house on the day you select and can grab your pie from the little window to the left, or there’s a pie fridge on the porch if Shannon isn’t there for a warm hand off. So happy to have a pie person in the area!
